I’ve been writing a Christmas song this week called His Tiny Hands, and it’s reminded me of something I often come back to in songwriting: sometimes the smallest moment can carry the biggest story.
Christmas is a tricky subject to write about. There are thousands of songs already out there, and so many familiar images and phrases. So how do you find something fresh?
For me, the answer was to stop looking at the whole story and zoom in on one tiny moment.
Finding a different perspective
I started imagining an old shepherd visiting a newborn baby. Not the whole Christmas story, with the crowds, the angels and the star. Just an old man kneeling beside a manger.
Then I imagined the baby reaching out and touching his hand. Two hands, one tiny and new, the other weathered by a lifetime of work.
That contrast caught my attention, and suddenly I had something I wanted to write about.
Finding the Song Map
Before writing too much of the lyric, I began thinking about where the story could go. I decided to explore a Gradual Reveal Song Map, where the meaning unfolds as the song progresses rather than being given away at the beginning.
The first verse would introduce the shepherd, the setting and that initial encounter. The chorus would focus on those tiny hands and the significance of that brief connection.
The second verse would develop the story with another detail or observation, giving the listener something new to discover.
Then the bridge could open up the bigger picture, revealing something that gives those earlier moments a deeper meaning.
Finally, we’d return to the chorus. The words might be exactly the same, but by now the listener would hear them differently.
That’s what I love about Song Maps. They help you think about the journey of the song before getting lost in individual lines.
Making the lyric feel real
Here’s part of the first verse:
I knelt beside that bed of hay
And Mary let me near
His fingers brushed
My weathered hand
And somehow eased my fear
I wanted the language to be simple. Nothing grand or overly poetic. Just someone describing what happened.
I particularly liked the contrast between “His fingers” and “my weathered hand.” Those few words give us a sense of both characters without needing to explain anything.
It’s a useful reminder that we don’t always need lots of description. Sometimes one carefully chosen detail can do the work of several lines.
The challenge of writing conversationally
One of the chorus lines I’ve been working on is:
He reached for me, and I reached back
I love the simplicity of that. It’s something someone might actually say, and there’s a little story in it. One person reaches out, and the other responds.
But I’ve also been wrestling with another couple of lines:
One small touch
Meant so much
They rhyme, and the rhythm works. But do they really say enough?
“Meant so much” tells us how the singer feels rather than allowing us to discover it for ourselves. That’s one of the little traps we can fall into as songwriters.
A line can rhyme perfectly and still not be the right line.
Sometimes we have to let go of a perfectly good rhyme to find something more meaningful. And sometimes those three or four little words take longer to get right than an entire verse!
Letting the listener do some of the work
Another line in the chorus is:
I couldn’t know what heaven really planned
What’s interesting here is the storytelling technique. The character is experiencing something without understanding its full significance, but the listener knows more. It’s a lovely device to use in songwriting.
Think about a song where someone remembers the first time they met the person they’d eventually marry. At the time, it was just an ordinary conversation. Years later, that moment means everything.
The singer can take us back to that first meeting, allowing us to experience it through their younger eyes, while we understand what those two people couldn’t possibly have known at the time.
That’s the same storytelling principle I’m exploring in His Tiny Hands. The listener brings their own understanding to the story, so the lyric doesn’t have to explain everything.
A little exercise for your next song
Think of a big subject you’d like to write about. It might be love, family, loss, friendship, forgiveness or home.
Now try finding one small, ordinary moment that might carry the meaning of that subject. A hand on someone’s shoulder, a half-finished cup of coffee, a familiar coat hanging by the door, or a goodbye at a railway station.
Instead of explaining what the subject means, describe that moment. Give us something we can see, hear or feel.
Then think about what the character knows at the beginning, what the listener might discover along the way, and how the final chorus could mean something more than the first.
You might find you’ve got the beginnings of a Gradual Reveal Song Map.
One small moment. One big story.
I’m still writing His Tiny Hands. There are lines I’m happy with and others I’ll probably rewrite several more times. That’s all part of the process.
But the important thing is that I’ve found the central image and a Song Map to help develop it. And that’s often the hardest part.
You don’t always need a completely new subject to write a fresh song. Sometimes you just need a new way of looking at something familiar.
Hope this helps!
Simon


